• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS
  • Twitter
South Muskoka Doppler

South Muskoka Doppler

Read Local

  • Home
    • All Stories
    • Community Guidelines
  • COVID-19
  • News
  • Community
  • Commentary
    • Letters
  • Business
    • Professionally Speaking
  • Sports
  • Obituaries
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
  • Events
    • Event Listings
    • Add Your Event
  • Speak Up, South Muskoka!
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
  • North Muskoka
  • Art Fx
You are here: Home / Community / Our energy future: a mini-series on the energy transition and Canada’s role in it | Commentary
(pixabay.com)

Our energy future: a mini-series on the energy transition and Canada’s role in it | Commentary

By Matt Driscoll On October 25, 2021 Community

Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin
Email this to someone
email
Print this page
Print

By Dave Wilkin

Affordable energy sits at the very foundation of modern economies, underpinning the lifestyle we enjoy today.

The past quarter-century has seen rapidly rising energy and fossil fuel consumption as billions of people have risen out of energy poverty and into middle-class and above lifestyles. This is positive, but it came at the price of steadily rising emissions with increasingly concerning consequences. Time is now running down for the enormous structural changes that will be needed if the world is to reach the ambitious emissions targets being set.  

Unfortunately, the energy transformation choices, costs, and implications are poorly understood by most people. The picture has become more clouded by academics and politicians who mostly don’t have experience working in the energy industry and thus lack firsthand knowledge, or they have other interests. A climate-emergency narrative pushed consistently by the media is drowning out other voices and obscuring a fuller understanding of the energy transition big picture. 

Rhetoric aside, the key question remains: what transition path will countries choose? Too slow a global transition to clean energy means increasing emissions and rising demand for more coal and more costly unconventional oil and gas to meet steadily growing energy demand. Too rapid a transition by prematurely curtailing fossil fuels before affordable viable alternatives are in place will lead to severe economic damage while condemning billions of people to continuing energy poverty, meaning a world less fair and geopolitically less stable. The ideal path chosen should achieve a balance and be sustainable, thus real-world trade-offs are needed. The ramifications of choosing poorly are enormous, carrying the highest possible stakes.

A major early warning of the impacts of imbalance is now playing out in Europe, the world’s champion for rapid energy transition. A significant energy crisis is unfolding there as natural gas and coal prices have spiked over 400 per cent, pushing electricity prices far higher and fueling consumer price increases not seen since 2008. With winter fast approaching and fossil fuel storage levels at unusual lows, the crisis is expected to worsen, bringing further economic disruption to recovering economies and hardship to many more families and businesses.

It’s not just confined to Europe either. Many other countries, most notably China and India, are also feeling the impacts of fossil fuel supply shortages and spiking energy prices, causing roaming power blackouts as systemic supply-demand imbalances take hold. 

Inappropriate government energy policy, environmental activism, and ESG investor pressures have all taken their toll by reducing needed fossil fuel investments necessary to maintain adequate supply in the face of rising demand.

Europe’s energy crisis is the biggest wake-up call yet on the consequences of poor energy transition planning. Europe has been closing down coal, gas, oil and even nuclear power generation for well over a decade, replacing it mostly with intermittent wind and solar power while simultaneously becoming more dependent on Russian natural gas. The past cold winter lowered fuel inventories, and a less windy and dry summer significantly reduced renewable power generation, placing further demands on fossil fuels. It’s surprising to see such stunningly poor energy planning from some of the wealthiest and most technically advanced countries in the world. For other nations watching, Europe’s attempt at a rapid transition is not the model to follow.

Yet, even in the face of this crisis, EU politicians and even the International Energy Agency are predictably calling for a faster transition led by much more wind and solar power. This crisis was not only foreseeable but inevitable, as most climate and energy policies have long been designed to drive fossil fuel prices higher. The obvious problem of course is the real hardship caused when sufficient, dependable alternatives aren’t in place. Note that EU power grid average share for wind plus solar is 18 per cent, and fossil fuels are about 40 per cent share (three-quarters of all primary energy). Recently California and Texas, both with wind/solar shares similar to Europe, also experienced significant power grid stresses and rolling blackouts.

As the consequences of poor planning and flawed policies bite hard, the 26th UN Climate Change Conference (COP26) in Glasgow (UK) should be interesting to watch to see what is learned from the crisis and what changes may follow. My guess is most western country leaders attending will ignore the obvious and justify an even faster transition away from fossil fuels. There are some clear signs of dissent though. Norway, Europe’s largest oil and gas producer, is planning to grow their oil and gas industry. In the US, President Biden’s aggressive climate agenda looks in jeopardy as US energy prices spike and resistance builds. Further, China’s President Xi Jinping and India’s PM Narendra Modi remain uncertain to attend and Russia’s president Vladimir Putin will not attend. Combined, these countries generate over 55 per cent of global energy related CO2 emissions. A disappointment to many, no doubt. 

Canadians need to understand the unvarnished truth on the energy choices ahead, the costs involved, the limitations and ramifications if we are to successfully navigate the turbulent waters and to seize the real opportunities presented. Current Canadian federal government climate and energy policy has us moving down a similar path as Europe, but at a far higher cost. Prematurely rapidly shuttering our large oil and gas sector would be an unprecedented self-inflicted catastrophe.

My next article in this energy mini-series takes a closer look at the global energy big picture to better understand what lies ahead. Watch for it!

Dave Wilkin is a Professional Engineer, with a master’s degree in Electrical Engineering from the University of Toronto. His career spans 45 years in IT, banking, energy and consulting. He lives in Huntsville, Ontario.

Don’t miss out on Doppler!

Sign up here to receive our email digest with links to our most recent stories.
Local news in your inbox three times per week!

Click here to support local news

Reader Interactions

Join the discussion:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments are moderated. Please ensure you include both your first and last name and abide by our community guidelines. Submissions that do not include the commenter's full name or that do not abide by our community guidelines will not be published.

Primary Sidebar

  • Recent Stories
  • Popular
  • August 6, 2022 3

    Is Muskoka going to the dogs?

  • July 18, 2022 3

    Councillor proposes Bracebridge-wide item swap weekends

  • August 8, 2022 2

    Muskoka Lakes considers indoor lighting restrictions

  • July 21, 2022 1

    Muskoka-wide crime spree lands man behind bars

  • August 8, 2022 1

    What on earth has happened to us? | Commentary

  • August 14, 2022 0

    How are we doing in our contributions to mitigate climate change? 

  • August 13, 2022 0

    Beaver Creek visitor charged with several offences

  • August 13, 2022 0

    Aspen Valley Wildlife Sanctuary seeks your support caring for wildlife in distress

  • August 13, 2022 0

    Letters: Tenuous taxi situation in Muskoka

  • August 12, 2022 0

     District passes accidental water leak policy

  • 2021 Federal Election (1)
  • A Sponsored Profile (6)
  • Advertise (1)
  • Art Fx (13)
  • Breaking (2)

Footer

About Doppler

Established by a bunch of local news hounds, Doppler strives to be the go-to source for people wanting to know more about what is going on their community.

We strive to provide local news that is relevant and timely. We also look to tell local stories that inspire, inform and engage.

Notice the persistent use of the word local? Our mantra is local. South Muskoka Doppler serves the communities of Bracebridge, Gravenhurst and Muskoka Lakes with features on local people doing extraordinary things, local business spotlights, news and sports coverage, all supplemented by provocative opinion pieces on topics near and far. We are working hard for you.

Feel free to drop us a line at matt.driscoll@doppleronline.ca and tell us how we are doing, what you would like to see more of, or to just say ‘Hi’.

Thank you for reading Doppler.

South Muskoka Doppler – READ LOCAL
A division of C3 Digital Media Group Inc.

Bracebridge Ontario Canada
August 14, 2022, 6:36 pm
Mostly cloudy
Mostly cloudy
24°C
real feel: 24°C
current pressure: 1020 mb
humidity: 38%
wind speed: 0 m/s N
wind gusts: 0 m/s
UV-Index: 1
sunrise: 6:18 am
sunset: 8:26 pm
© 2022 AccuWeather, Inc.
 

Recent Comments

  • Jackson Triggs on Wakes, noise and speed: Lakes survey reflects growing frustrations
  • Robert Dyment on Graydon Smith faces charges laid by private citizen
  • brian sisler on One person dead, one injured in Bracebridge shooting
  • RJR on What on earth has happened to us? | Commentary
  • RJR on Is Muskoka going to the dogs?
  • Heather Boyce on Muskoka Lakes considers indoor lighting restrictions
  • Bob Braan on Muskoka Lakes considers indoor lighting restrictions
  • Bob Braan on Is Muskoka going to the dogs?

Copyright © 2022 ·Doppler Online, a division of C3 Digital Media Group Inc. · Log in
  • About
  • Support Local News
  • Advertise with us!
  • Community Guidelines
  • Contact